Ninth Schedule of Indian Constitution: UPSC Notes, Article 31B and Key Cases
The Ninth Schedule, added by the First Amendment in 1951 with Article 31B, protects listed laws from Fundamental Rights challenges. These UPSC notes cover its origin, growth to 284 entries, the Waman Rao and I.R. Coelho judgments, a Mains answer framework and practice MCQs.
On this page
The Ninth Schedule of the Indian Constitution is a list of Central and State laws that are protected from being struck down only because they violate Fundamental Rights. It was added by the Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951, together with Article 31B, to save land reform laws from court challenges. Since the Supreme Court's I.R. Coelho judgment of 11 January 2007, laws placed in the schedule after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the basic structure of the Constitution. These UPSC notes explain the schedule, the cases that shaped it and how to write about it in Prelims and Mains.
Ninth Schedule at a glance
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Added by | Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951 |
| Linked article | Article 31B (validation of certain Acts and Regulations) |
| Original entries | 13 laws, all on land reform and the abolition of zamindari |
| Entries today | Numbered up to 284; entries 258 to 284 were added by the 78th Amendment, 1995 |
| How a law is added | Only by a constitutional amendment passed by Parliament under Article 368, even for a State law |
| Key cut-off date | 24 April 1973, the date of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment |
| Leading case | I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu, nine-judge bench, 11 January 2007 |
What Article 31B says
Article 31B states that none of the Acts and Regulations listed in the Ninth Schedule, nor any of their provisions, shall be deemed void on the ground that they are inconsistent with or take away any of the rights conferred by Part III (Fundamental Rights). It applies even if a court has already declared the law void, so the protection works retrospectively. The competent legislature can still repeal or amend a listed law.
Three features are often tested:
- It protects against Part III challenges only. A listed law can still be struck down if the legislature that passed it had no power to make it under the Seventh Schedule.
- It is not limited to land reform. Article 31A covers specific categories such as the acquisition of estates, but Article 31B covers any law placed in the schedule.
- Inclusion needs an amendment. A State legislature cannot add its own law; Parliament must pass a constitutional amendment.
Why the Ninth Schedule was created
Soon after independence, States passed laws to abolish zamindari and redistribute land. Landowners challenged them under the right to property and the right to equality. In 1951 the Patna High Court struck down the Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950 in Kameshwar Singh v. State of Bihar. To protect the reform programme, the Nehru government moved the First Amendment, which inserted Articles 31A and 31B and the Ninth Schedule with 13 land laws. The Supreme Court upheld the First Amendment in Shankari Prasad v. Union of India (1951).
How the schedule grew
Over the following decades, many amendments added laws to the schedule. The additions moved well beyond land reform to include laws on ceilings, industrial undertakings, essential commodities and reservations. Important examples for exams:
- 76th Amendment, 1994: added the Tamil Nadu law providing 69 per cent reservation in educational institutions and State services (entry 257A).
- 78th Amendment, 1995: added land reform laws as entries 258 to 284, the last numbered entries.
- 44th Amendment, 1978: removed the right to property from Part III and made it a legal right under Article 300A, which reduced the original reason for many entries.
Critics argued that the schedule became a way to place laws beyond judicial review, which is why the Supreme Court later drew limits.
Supreme Court cases on the Ninth Schedule
| Case | Year | What it held |
|---|---|---|
| Shankari Prasad v. Union of India | 1951 | Upheld the First Amendment; Parliament could amend Fundamental Rights. |
| Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala | 24 April 1973 | Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution but cannot destroy its basic structure. |
| Waman Rao v. Union of India | 1981 | Amendments adding laws to the Ninth Schedule up to 24 April 1973 are valid; later additions are open to basic-structure review. |
| I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu | 11 January 2007 | Laws added on or after 24 April 1973 can be examined for whether they damage the basic structure, including the rights in Articles 14, 19 and 21 and the principles behind them. |
| Glanrock Estate v. State of Tamil Nadu | 2010 | Applied the Coelho test and upheld the Gudalur Janmam Estates law already placed in the schedule. |
The I.R. Coelho judgment explained
The question before the nine-judge bench was whether Parliament could use the Ninth Schedule to give laws complete immunity from Fundamental Rights. The Court answered no. Its main conclusions were:
- Every law added to the Ninth Schedule on or after 24 April 1973 is open to review.
- The test is whether the law damages or destroys the basic structure of the Constitution, judged by its actual effect on rights such as equality, freedoms and life and personal liberty.
- If a law in the schedule has already been upheld by the Court, that decision is not reopened. A law struck down earlier cannot be revived only by placing it in the schedule if it violates the basic structure.
- Judicial review itself is part of the basic structure, so it cannot be fully excluded.
A common mistake is to write that the judgment was given in 1999. The case was referred to a larger bench in 1999, but the final judgment came on 11 January 2007.
Ninth Schedule for UPSC Mains: answer framework
A 150 or 250-word answer on the Ninth Schedule can follow this order:
- Introduction: the First Amendment, Article 31B and the purpose of protecting land reforms.
- Evolution: growth from 13 to 284 entries and the move beyond land reform.
- Judicial response: Kesavananda Bharati, Waman Rao and I.R. Coelho.
- Assessment: social justice goals on one side, misuse to shield laws from scrutiny on the other.
- Conclusion: the schedule survives, but as limited protection balanced by judicial review.
Ninth Schedule vs other schedules
The Constitution now has 12 schedules. Students often confuse the Ninth with these:
- Seventh Schedule: Union, State and Concurrent Lists of legislative subjects.
- Eighth Schedule: the 22 recognised languages.
- Tenth Schedule: anti-defection law, added by the 52nd Amendment, 1985.
Quick revision
- Added by the First Amendment, 1951, with Articles 31A and 31B.
- Started with 13 land reform laws; entries now run to 284.
- Protects listed laws from challenges under Part III only.
- Only Parliament can add a law, through a constitutional amendment.
- Laws added on or after 24 April 1973 are open to basic-structure review (Waman Rao, 1981; I.R. Coelho, 2007).
Practice MCQs
1. The Ninth Schedule was added to the Constitution by which amendment?
A) 1st Amendment, 1951 B) 7th Amendment, 1956 C) 24th Amendment, 1971 D) 42nd Amendment, 1976
Answer: A. The First Amendment, 1951 inserted Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule.
2. Which article protects laws in the Ninth Schedule?
A) Article 31A B) Article 31B C) Article 31C D) Article 300A
Answer: B. Article 31B validates the Acts listed in the Ninth Schedule.
3. In I.R. Coelho, laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after which date were held open to basic-structure review?
A) 26 January 1950 B) 24 April 1973 C) 25 June 1975 D) 1 April 1979
Answer: B. 24 April 1973 is the date of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment.
4. Consider the statements: (1) A State legislature can place its own law in the Ninth Schedule. (2) A listed law can be challenged for lack of legislative competence. Which is correct?
A) 1 only B) 2 only C) Both D) Neither
Answer: B. Only Parliament can add laws through a constitutional amendment, and Article 31B does not cure lack of legislative power.
5. The Tamil Nadu law providing 69 per cent reservation was placed in the Ninth Schedule by the
A) 73rd Amendment B) 76th Amendment C) 77th Amendment D) 81st Amendment
Answer: B. The 76th Amendment, 1994.
For more practice, try the 40 Indian Constitution MCQ questions and answers.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Ninth Schedule of the Indian Constitution?
It is a list of laws protected by Article 31B from being declared void for violating Fundamental Rights. It was created in 1951 to protect land reform laws.
How many laws are in the Ninth Schedule?
The entries are numbered up to 284, with a few lettered entries such as 257A. Some entries were later omitted, so count the current list in the official text of the Constitution if an exact figure is needed.
Are Ninth Schedule laws beyond judicial review?
No. Laws added on or after 24 April 1973 can be reviewed for violation of the basic structure, as held in I.R. Coelho (2007).
What is the difference between Article 31A and Article 31B?
Article 31A saves specific categories of laws, such as those acquiring estates, from challenge under Articles 14 and 19. Article 31B protects any law listed in the Ninth Schedule from challenge under any Fundamental Right.
Continue your preparation
Sources & Further Reading
| Document / Website | Link |
|---|---|
| Legislative Department: Constitution of India (updated text) | Open Legislative Department: Constitution of India (updated text) ↗www.legislative.gov.in |
| Belling the Cat: The Curious Case of the Ninth Schedule in the Indian Constitution | Open Belling the Cat: The Curious Case of the Ninth Schedule in the Indian Constitution ↗repository.nls.ac.in |
| NINTH SCHEDULE TO CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : A STUDY | JSTOR | Open NINTH SCHEDULE TO CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : A STUDY | JSTOR ↗www.jstor.org |
| The Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951 | Current Affairs | Open The Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951 | Current Affairs ↗www.shankariasparliament.com |
| Supreme Court: I.R. Coelho judgment, 11 January 2007 | Open Supreme Court: I.R. Coelho judgment, 11 January 2007 ↗cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in |